upvote
(I will be copy/paste this answer for the other comments)

My bad - I misread the post.

To clear things up: I am completely aware about how to store passwords in services that check against them. You are likely to have read some of my prose on that topic in OWASP or at a conference :)

My point, after misreading the article, was that in order to authenticate to a service (the one that holds the hashed version of that password) you need to have access to its cleartext version. This is VERY bad, should never be stored without special considerations etc.

I read the articlae as if they accessed the source of the passwords, the one used to access to services (a vault, with its encryption, access restrictions etc.). 5k was a lot but that could have been bearers or similar ones.

So my comment, and the comments to it, actually yelled at me (that's good!) the way I yell at actual implemententions sometimes :)

In all seriousness - thanks for the reaction, we need more of these. My next obsession are servies that require "only digits" or "strictly 8 to 11 chars" for credentials :)

reply
You should have stuck with the 'My bad...' and left out the eye-roll inducing humble brags and inscrutable non-clarifications. But what do I know...I've only been an infosec practitioner since the early 90s...I'm sure 'conference experience' trumps that.

(I will not 'be copy/paste' (?) this response everywhere you spammed someone who pointed out the glaringly obvious)

reply
Or I could have let it go.

See, I respect people who point out mistakes, and explain why I did it.

Why did I mention that I do security? Because I spent the last, 25 years trying to push proper practices and did not want to jump into discussions where over 10 comments we would end up flexing about details.

Since you are an infosec practitioner since the early 90s you either are a saint, or did not have to yell through best practices to just let it go.

Not sure what you don't like about conferences? Never got anything from them? I did and I am sure glad to have listened to great presentations.

reply
You should have stuck with "Or I could have let it go.".
reply
And yet I have not, sorry for having dissapointed you.
reply