undefined

points

[-]

I’d settle for at least a high school physics education. This idea seemed insane when I first heard about it a few weeks back. This analysis just makes it that much more crazy.

If YC is hell bent on lighting piles of money on fire, I can think of some more enjoyable ways.

by throwawaymaths14 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

they got the sun synchronous orbit part right.

by Robotbeat13 hours ago|

prev|

[-]

Radiation is not actually a problem unless you're trying to do super high power nuclear electric propulsion (i.e. in your videogame). Classic armchair engineer mistake, tbh.

Radiators work great in space. Stefan-Boltzmann's law. The ISS's solar panels are MUCH smaller than the radiators. Considering datacenters on Earth have to have massive heat exchangers as well, I really think the bUt wHaT aBoUt rAdiAtOrs is an overblown gotcha, considering every satellite still has to dump heat and works just fine.

by semi-extrinsic12 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

The problem is not that radiators don't work. The problem is the need for liquid cooling. The heat prduced per area in the GPU/CPU is much bigger than the cooling capacity per area of your radiator.

Even here on earth, contemporary GPU racks for AI have had to move to liquid cooling because it is the only way to extract enough heat. At 120 kW for 18x 1U servers (GB200 NVL72), the power density is waaay beyond what you can do with air even.

The last time Starcloud was doing the rounds on HN, I estimated that they need to be pumping water at a flow rate of 60 000 liters per second, if you use the numbers in their whitepaper. That's a tenth of the Sacramento river, flowing in space through a network with a million junctions and hoping nothing leaks.

by fennecfoxy8 hours ago|

parent|

prev|

[-]

There's a difference between a couple humans (n150W) and say JUST one H200 DGX (8700W).

by throwawaymaths2 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

yes. in general as a rule of thumb your radiator size must scale proportionally to your solar panel size, as parent says:

> The ISS's solar panels are MUCH smaller than the radiators.