upvote
Getting that laptop into your hands required one of the most sophisticated supply chains in human history to be built up. Tens of millions of people all had to work together at a distance, many of them doing things dozens of steps removed from the final product, in order to make it so that you could purchase that laptop. Money is the lifeblood of that entire system, the coordination mechanism that makes such things possible, and the instant you purchase that laptop you have injected more such blood into it to diffuse out.

That's an enormous impact even if all you did with the laptop immediately after purchasing it was throw it in a volcano. It's not wrong to realize that money is subject to diminishing returns like everything else, but it misses the most important thing about it, and that exists outside of you.

reply
There are 2 concepts here. Problem with internet forums is the combinatorial explosion in points to talk to!

So the impact that the adoption of fungible value by human society. As you alluded to: unspeakably big and arguably good overall (lets see the next 200 years before we judge but lets say massively positive. We got vaccines and space travel.)

Obviously it is not all attributable to money. It is the inventions from the wheel to the sexstant, the schools, socialism, capitalism, invention of writing, religion, even war etc. etc.

On the other hand, "Impact is money and money is Impact". is not true.

A teacher gets a fixed wage. They can be a great teacher and inspire the kids to do great things, or they could make the kids feel insecure for life. Same dollar wage both ways.

reply
Money is more than one thing.

It's a "tool", currency for exchange, but also a store of value, a unit of accounting, etc. etc.

A few hundred dollar notes in your wallet is a tool you can use to buy food and pay rent for a while. A company worth a few million is a measure of the impact, value to customers, net present value of future income/cashflows, etc.

reply