upvote
What is it with people feeling compelled to talk about starship troopers movie being different (lesser) than the book?

Like, there's not that much to the book. It's a decently written "joins the military" story with a couple of well developed characters and one unique idea about sci-fi warfare (the suits spending most of their time jumping, which in retrospect would just make you a giant target...)

None of this is bad, it's just like, there's dozens of other mil-sci-fi books and yet everyone has to jump in and go "but the book is better!!!"

reply
deleted
reply
Bastardized? It's satire and not at all subtle about it. You can of course argue that it's poorly executed satire, but judging it based on how faithful it is to the source material is rather missing the point.
reply
I think you're the one who missed the point, as in you missed *my* point.

When I first saw Starship Troopers, I disliked it because it wasn't faithful to the book. Over time I came to appreciate it for what it actually was, and now think it is fantastic.

Likewise, with Hackers I initially disliked it due to how inaccurate and unrealistic it was. I came to appreciate it for what it actually was over time, and now think it is fantastic.

reply
Yeah, my bad. For some reason I read your comment really carelessly.
reply

  > I think you're the one who missed the point
Yes, I would like to know more ..
reply
I'm doing my part!
reply
Ha, caught that reference. That brought back memories.
reply