upvote

points

by coldtea10 hours ago |
comments
upvoteby zozbot2349 hours ago|
[-]
Call center workers are bound to a fixed script, they're basically humans who play robot as their job. Replacing this with AI is a welcome development. As for jobs like translator, graphic designer and journalist, it's only the extremely low-end work that can possibly be replaced with LLMs. Not an issue if they move upmarket.

> And there's no shortage of companies press releases about cutting down thousands of jobs and saying it's because they leverage AI.

These press releases are largely fake. "We're leveraging AI now" sounds a lot better than "whoops, looks like we overhired, we have to scale back and layoff workers because there's no demand for what we're doing".

reply
upvoteby coldtea9 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
>Replacing this with AI is a welcome development.

Not if you fed your kid doing it, and now you can't.

> As for jobs like translator, graphic designer and journalist, it's only the extremely low-end work that can possibly be replaced with LLMs. Not an issue if they move upmarket.

Yes, fuck the 90% of those working in that space, and let's hope the 10% gets an "upmarket" gig there.

All this grand-visioning sounds devoid of empathy and real understanding of millions of real people's situations and needs.

reply
upvoteby zozbot2349 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
> Not if you fed your kid doing it, and now you can't.

Which happens all the time anyway. There just aren't that many people for whom being a call center worker is their long-term career, they'll just switch to some other job.

reply
upvoteby doctorwho427 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
What other jobs? I hate how people just throw that out as a viable path. In a world with ever increasing wealth inequality there is lower velocity of money (lower available cash flow) to enable the creation of jobs. And just pointing to the industrial revolution is not the panacea that you think it is. Past economic/tech revolutions creating new jobs, I have yet to see anyone point to a vast creation of jobs (or at least the starting trend of job creation)... Instead all the news, all the discussions, everything has been about (directly or indirectly) the decreased need for as many workers or the increased production of workers with the tools (which indirectly implies a decrease in workforce)
reply
upvoteby SkyeCA7 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
> What other jobs? I hate how people just throw that out as a viable path.

People on HN are extremely privileged and massively out of touch with the average normal person, what's new?

reply
upvoteby coldtea8 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
There are millions upon millions of people where there is no "long-term career" period, just regular shitty and more shitty gig jobs and low end work like this, from factories and workcenters to burger flipping, to deliveries, loading, to cleaning, and everything in between. And they are getting increasingly squeezed and out of options.
reply
upvoteby direwolf208 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
This works until we run out of sensible jobs, which may have already happened.
reply