upvote
That seems wrong. If malware can fake what the authenticator shows me, the authenticator is broken!

It doesn't matter what device relays the code I typed over or otherwise transmits the approval through untrusted networks to the server

> The sad reality is that phones (and some tablets) are the only relatively secure computing environments that we have

My bank('s authenticator hardware) begs to differ

reply
That seems wrong. If malware can fake what the authenticator shows me, the authenticator is broken!

That's not what I am saying. The authenticator is irrelavant to this attack. If your machine is compromised by malware, the malware could take over the browser session, regardless of how you log in.

Phones are better protected against persistent malware because every application is sandboxed (harder to escalate) and much more of the boot chain/OS is validated (harder to persist).

reply