As arguments go, this is not bad, as we tend to have some expectations about 'truth in advertising' ( however watered-down it may be at this point ). Still, I am not sure I ever saw openAI, Claude or other providers claim something akin to:
reply- it will find you a new mate - it will improve your sex life - it will pay your taxes - it will accurately diagnose you
That is, unless I somehow missed some targeted advertising material. If it helps, I am somewhere in the middle myself. I use llms ( both at work and privately ). Where I might slightly deviate from the norm is that I use both unpaid versions ( gemini ) and paid ones ( chatgpt ) apart from my local inference machine. I still think there is more value in letting people touch the hot stove. It is the only way to learn.