>In 2021 the US had the its best opportunity to date to assemble a military tribunal to try and then execute a President
replyIt's completely foreign to the US or the Anglo-Saxon world in general. The military as the final guarantor of state security is a continental European thing (and removing this has been the goal of many army reforms in Europe since the end of WW2).
The modern anglo-saxon world has been pretty limited in this respect - but Charles I of England is an excellent example of pretty much just this playing out and being solved with a national razor.
replyI agree with you - I should've caveated that the Anglo-Saxon aversion to military coups comes precisely from Cromwell IMO.
replyThis sounds similar to holding up Ghandi as
proof that violent rebellion is not
necessary. Treating these incidents as proof
about the current world presumes people in power
lack the agency to examine history like
the rest of us.
replyThis is a nonsensical reform. Every check and balance is itself
a risk, nonetheless one can not build a safe Republic by removing
them.
replyThe US thinks it is the check for Europe but this offers no check for the leader of a superpower such as the US.
(It's apparently a flaggable offense to believe a legitimate republic is measured by making sense even if making sense goes against Anglo Saxon sensibilities since Cromwell.. I guess we can call time of death on the city on a hill.)
Well if you want the possibility of military tribunals you have to accept the risks of something like the 1962 Algiers coup, the 27 May revolution or (if you want a more recent example) the Wagner rebellion. I'm not certain that would be palatable to Americans but I'm not American myself so wouldn't know.
replyI grew up in an America that spent a lot
to explain what it was willing to do for
a Republic and ideals. The people who will
quietly give a traitor an illegal 3rd term
to avoid a more upsetting crises that
could either save the Republic or just
make it clearer it is over are
apparently what the US actually is.
reply[flagged]
reply