Let's say instead of reversing, the job was to pick apples. Let's say an AI can pick all the apples in an orchard in normal weather conditions, but add overcast skies and success drops to zero. Is this, in your opinion, still a skilled apple picking specialist?
No hate. My only point is that’s it’s easy for analogies to fail. I can’t tell the point of either of your analogies, where the OP made several clear and cogent points.