Same. I agree that it is unappealing but it can be done in a way that respects anonymity.
I built this and talk about it here: https://blog.picheta.me/post/the-future-of-social-media-is-h...
I think we’re on the precipice of this being a requirement to have any faith you’re talking to another human. As a side effect it also helps avoid state actors from influencing others.
Except that it doesn't prove you're talking to a human - it just increases the hurdles for bot operators (buy or steal verified accounts).
Regarding your implementation: Most people don't have a passport, so it's a non-starter - but again, this topic is not a technical issue.
I don't see that as "requiring ID".
I think the real question is how much do we care that our online spaces are composed of not just AI bots, but also sock puppet accounts controlled by various people (from governments, rich people, all the way to harassers that use alt accounts) wanting to trick us.
One of the things HN does is not let you interact in certain ways until you've earned sufficient karma. This is a basic proof-of-work. If your bot can't average a positive karma, then it'll never get certain privileges.
Not to say the system is perfectly tuned for bots, because it's not. The point is that proof of identity is not the only option.
HN is doing okay at the moment because nobody is yet publishing ebooks and videos on how to astroturf HN to launch your SaaS. Unfortunately, Reddit hasn’t escaped that fate.
Many of them sound and look completely normal and have others on here interacting with them. They don't use em dashes, sometimes they'll use all lowercase text, sometimes the owner of the bot will come out and start commenting to throw you off.
All examples I've witnessed here.
HN should immediately start implementing at least some basic bot detection methods without requiring us to email them every time. I've discovered multiple bots make detailed comments within 30 seconds of each other in different threads, something a normal human wouldn't be able to do. That should be at least flagging the account for review. Obviously they'll get smarter and not do that soon but it would help in the short term.
I'd say it's not an issue but everything I described above has happened in less than a month and every day now I'm discovering bots here.
My conspiracy theory: Campaign money, from the last few elections (I think "Correct the record" [1] was the first "disclosed" push), resulted in a bunch of bot accounts being made/bought all across social media. These are being lightly used to maintained some reasonably realistic usage statistics, and are "activated" to respond to key political topics/times. This is on top of spam accounts to push products and, of course, the probably higher-than-average bot number of accounts, made for fun, by HN users.