Of course they're not rocket science. But, the question here is, "Why don't you use random 16 bytes instead of a UUIDv4?" It's not a question about rocket science. The answer is still, "Because UUIDv4 is still a better way to do it." The UUID standard solves the second and third tier problems and knock-on effects you don't think about until you've run a system for awhile, or until you start adding multiple information systems that need to interact with the same data.

But, using UUIDv4 shouldn't be rocket science, either. UUID support should be built in to a language intended for web applications, database applications, or business applications. That's why you're using Go or C# instead of C. And Go is somewhat focused on micro-service architectures. It's going to need to serialize and deserialize objects regularly.

What do they look like when I put it in a url?

> There's no serialization.

Hex encoding with hyphens in the right spot isn't serialization?

Vibe endian

> serialize to a string and store in a db

Ah, here we are. If it's just bytes, why store it as a string? Sixteen bytes is just a 128-bit integer, don't waste the space. So now the DB needs to know how to convert your string back to an integer. And back to a string when you ask for it.

"Well why not just keep it as an integer?"

Sure, in which base? With leading zeroes as padding?

But now you also need to handle this in JavaScript, where you have to know to deserialize it to a Bigint or Buffer (or Uint8Array).

UUIDs just mean you don't need to do any of this crap yourself. It's already there and it already works. Everything everywhere speaks the same UUIDs.

You have to generate random bytes with sufficient entropy to avoid collisions and you have to have a consistent way to serialize it to a string. There's already a standard for this, it's called UUID.

It’s really not that complicated a problem. Don’t worry, you’ll certainly be able to solve all the problems yourself as you encounter them. What you end up with will be functionally equivalent to a proper UUID and will only have cost you man-months of pain, but then you will be able to truly understand the benefit of not spending your effort on easy problems that someone solved before you.

It's not a huge problem. Uuid adds convenience over reinventing that wheel everywhere. And some of those wheels would use the wrong random or hash or encoding.

(Downvote wasn't me)