upvote
Hi Bruno - this looks great! I remember collaborating with you a couple times on Kagi's browser extensions. Was there a specific moment that made you want to work on Uruky, or was it because of the overall direction Kagi is heading in?
reply
Hey Alabhya! Nice seeing you here! :)

I don't think Kagi is heading in a necessarily "bad" direction, though I don't agree with it, and I also think there's value in a product that's solely focused on private and personal search, that doesn't have to be as expensive, expansive (Drive, Maps, Email, etc.) or big (team and resources-wise) as they are.

I hope that makes sense!

reply
This sounds great, and I like it being EU-based (and, presumably, not reusing Yandex like Kagi famously does?)

Could you share more info about how you're building it? Like Kagi it wraps / reuses multiple other providers? How do you do that affordably, and how do you merge the results together into a good answer?

reply
Thanks! Sure. We are 100% transparent on all the search providers we're using, you can see them in the FAQ, and Yandex isn't used.

Initially we called all search providers and merged the results in a round robin fashion (so first of the first provider, first of the second provider, first of the third provider, then second of the first provider, second of the second provider, and so on), deduplicating them, but this was becoming very costly and inefficient once we had 3 and more search providers (most providers will return results within 500ms, but not infrequently one would take up to 2s or more — we timeout there, so I don't know if it'd take much more —, slowing everything down), so now we give everyone the choice of which providers to use first, and we pick results from the first two (we're actually considering switching to just the first, as costs are still a bit high and we don't want to increase pricing).

I hope that provides some more clarity! Happy to answer any more questions.

reply
I know Kagi is using Yandex (Russian search engine), that's why I am no longer using it.

Is Uruky using Yandex?

reply
Hello! We are 100% transparent on all the search providers we're using, you can see them in the FAQ, and Yandex isn't used.
reply
Very cool, wishing you the best of luck with this.

One bit of feedback from me, take it or leave it, but the name doesn't feel appealing or memorable. What does it mean?

reply
Thanks! We'll happily take suggestions, but I read it like "Euro-key". My wife also doesn't love the name, but we couldn't come up with (or find) anything with 5 letters or less that sounded decent so far.

There's no specific meaning, though I can't say I dislike the close name matches with Uruk-hai [1] and Uruk [2]! :)

[1]: https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Uruk-hai

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uruk

reply
It makes me think of the Uruk-hai from Lord of the Rings. To me that is not a positive connotation. I feel bad writing anything even slightly negative about what is a really, really awesome project, though, and I hope that you meet with success :)
reply
Thanks for the kind words! They might not be "standard pretty" but I'd say they're arguably resilient and disciplined, so it's not all bad! :D
reply
Given the notorious European branding, consider renaming it eureuky ;-)
reply
Haha! I definitely read it "euro-key", but we wanted fewer letters! :D
reply