upvote
Can you expand on this? You definitely don’t need 6 months for a note taking app to be useable it is more you need to compete with the state of the art right
reply
I'd argue you need between 6 minutes and 6 years.

It depends entirely on what you want. You can literally code a JavaScript 1-liner that will make a <textarea> then put the content back in the URL and it will work serverless on pretty much any platform with a Web browser.

You can also write a note taking app that will be federated yet private, that will have its own scripting language, etc. I mean you can yak-shave your way to write your own OS or even designing your own CPU for that.

So... I'm not sure that metric, time, means much without a proper context, including who does it. It's quite different if to do that, regardless of the tooling used, if you are a professional developer, designer, fullstack dev, prototypist, PM, marketer, writer, etc.

reply
> Can you expand on this?

sure. does your note taking app supports formatting? you don't need it today. you will need it at some point. images? same.

does it handle file corruption etc? no? then its pretty much useless.

does it work across devices? in modern world, again, it is pretty much useless without it

it works across devices? then it needs hosting. if it is hosted it needs auth, it needs backups

you can go on for ever.

the bar for very minimal note taking app that you actually will use is very high, with other software it is even higher.

and this is not even state of art, this is must haves

reply
Obsidian is super popular and is generally local first and device specific.

And even so if your starting a note taking app most of those problems like file corruption and image support are largely solved problems. There is also the benefit of being able to reference tons of open source implementations.

I think one month to notion like app that is prod ready if you just need Auth + markdown + images + standard text editing

reply
What universe do you live in
reply
>with all vibe coding in the world today you still need at least 6 months full time to build a nice note taking app.

Bad example, note apps loaded with features are anti-productive and are for people who treat note taking as a hobby itself.

You have Obsidian anyway if you want something open source to work with.

reply
I don't disagree, but I found it ironic I built ZenPlan, my ideal hybrid task/notetaking app, in about 50 hours with Claude Code this month after being frustrated with notebook and task management sprawl in OneNote. www.getzenplan.com
reply
Ah, note taking as hobby finally explains to me why these apps seem so popular. I don't think I have ever considered that I need one. And it to be something that shouldn't be fully solved multiple times now. But it really being hobby does kinda make the point for me.
reply
obsidian isn't open source
reply
You seem to be making the assumption that "app" means "sellable product", rather than "one off that works for me". It doesn't.

When everyone is able to make their own one off prototype in 30 minutes, no one will pay for the thing that took someone 6 months.

reply
whatever you prototype - the one who built it in 6 month will have economy of scale to make it cheaper than your diy solution, and because they serve many customers and developed it for 6 months - their product will be 100x better than the one you diy

there is very very rare use case when diy makes sense. in 99% of cases its just a toy that feels nice as you kinda did it. but if you factor in the time etc it is always costs 100x more than $5/month you could usually buy

reply
Based on your earlier comment and your last paragraph, your impression of AI vibe coding ability is at least a year out of date.

In late 2024 it might have taken 6 months. Today, two weeks, maybe 3.

reply