upvote
"Need" might be strong, but I am okay with music players. My ADHD self is able to focus many times better if I have certain kinds of music playing to block out nearly talking and other distracting sounds.
reply
I gave my 16yo ADHD kid an mp3 player with hours of “ADHD focus” music on it.

It’s proven very useful a few times where a few ND-unaware teachers have confiscated phones that the ND kids use to help them focus.

They don’t get it to use it whenever they want but there are some situations where they are allowed to use it and where having a phone is tricky given the lack of trust some teachers have.

Old school technology fallbacks are sometimes useful. Who knew.

reply
Having all been in high school, I think we can all agree that lack of trust is warranted. Not for every kid, but for enough of them that blanket rules make sense. We also don’t allow students to use the calculator app on their phone for tests, and instead make them buy the “old school technology fallback” version.

An MP3 player seems like a good compromise, and far cheaper than the phone they’re replacing.

reply
Listening to music can help people focus.
reply
In 2026 the number of people with mp3 players that are not also smart phones is vanishingly small.
reply
If you are interested in standalone digital audio players (DAPs), I just recently bought this:

https://www.fiio.com/echomini

For ~$60 you get a device that can play every type of audio file and has better sound quality than your cellphone + streamer combo.

I've been reading more about Chinese hardware and if you've been sleeping on it there are a lot of great Chinese consumer products that are both extremely high quality + very cheap.

Turns out when you have tens of millions of engineers they pump out banger after banger. Also always hilarious, in an enduring way, finding the factory engineers engaging with consumers on random forums that take their feedback seriously.

reply
Note that in this case, you are getting what you pay for: I had a FIIO DAC that sounded amazing but was really bad about full-scale turn-on, sync and desync pops to the extent that it damaged my speakers. Yes, perfect power sequence hygiene would have prevented the problem, but one can't always be ready with the amplifier volume knob when their playback system crashes.
reply
ah good to know. Outside of having a very basic dac for my cans on my desktop, I wouldn't think of any serious equipment failures could happen. Probably wrong to assume that these things are engineered to be safe/redundant.

This is going to be my first DAP in like 15 years, zune being the last one I had. Pretty excited to rock it out for a bit.

There's a current fad out there to move to more single-service type of devices rather than using a phone for everything. Want to try it out myself to be more intentional with my digital actions and ween myself away from corporate social media.

reply
Woah, skeuomorphism writ large!
reply
If they're allowed and help where phones wouldn't or don't there are still lots of options for stand alone MP3 players with minimal or no connectivity. They still exist as a market because they're dirt cheap to make.
reply
music players were often essential for my ability to stay focussed on my work and reading.
reply
During class time?
reply
not all classes are 100% lectures. many of my kids classes have 15-30 minutes of "work time". sometimes entire periods are "work periods" when they have a big project or whatever.
reply
For the walk home
reply
I mostly just listened during homeroom and lunch period. But once I was sent to in-schoool-suspension in high school in the early 2000s for listening to my mp3 player (Diamond Rio PMP300) after I finished taking the yearly standardized tests the state used to judge schools.
reply