upvote

points

by hmartin22 hours ago |
comments
upvoteby sneak21 hours ago|
[-]
Flighty is poorly designed.

It’s one of those slick apps designed to superficially look nice without actually being well-thought-out. That’s not what design is or should mean; that’s just aesthetics.

Case in point: one of the most important pieces of data for a flight, its duration, is displayed in the tiniest type size on the flight info display pane, in light grey text on a slightly darker grey background. It’s bordering on illegible.

It also doesn’t surface boarding time (or countdown to same), which is the single most important piece of data a flight tracker can give you.

reply
upvoteby exidy21 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
> one of the most important pieces of data for a flight, its duration

Flighty is all about getting you to the airport in time for your flight, so the most important pieces of information are things like departure times, connection times, delay information, terminal and boarding gate. These are prioritised in the interface.

The flight duration is set when you book the flight and it's not going to change, there is no reason to prioritise this.

> It also doesn’t surface boarding time

I think this would be useful but difficult data to get. Airlines sometimes will push boarding announcements to their own apps but I doubt they would agree to feed Flighty.

reply
upvoteby yosito18 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
In my extensive travel experience, more than half the time the boarding time listed at the gate isn't even correct.
reply
upvoteby ymolodtsov14 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
Boarding times are basically not reliable at all. Any time I come 10m after the official boarding time on the ticket there's still a standing line.
reply
upvoteby ggsp14 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
My guess is that's because boarding a plane is a little bit like being an extra for a film, it's a hurry up and wait situation. If they printed the exact time boarding starts and people showed up then (and later), no flight would ever board on time. Better for the airline to print an earlier time and have people wait longer, so they can board as quickly as possible. Every minute behind schedule costs the airline money.
reply
upvoteby drdec6 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
AA displays the boarding time in the app instead of the departure time once the flight gets close enough (like same day)

>If they printed the exact time boarding starts and people showed up then (and later), no flight would ever board on time

I don't understand the logic. If everyone is there at the stated boarding time and the airline has correctly allocated enough time for boarding, aren't they winning?

reply
upvoteby donalhunt3 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
200 people can't board at the same second. Reality is you want orderly boarding over the course of ~ 10-15mins depending on passenger makeup. Crew also need to account for passenger with additional needs, catering recharge, etc
reply
upvoteby ymolodtsov13 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
Yes, and the actual time is probably too close to the official take off time.

But this is why Flighty probably doesn't show it, it's irrelevant.

reply
upvoteby japanuspus13 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
Just don't try this on Ryan Air. A good friend got stuck at the airport on a Sunday night after being denied boarding because he waited out the standing line sitting on a bench right by the gate. As soon as the last person standing walked through the checkpoint the gate crew closed the gate -- and completely ignored my friend when he showed up 10 seconds later.
reply
upvoteby gib4446 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
How did his actual boarding time match up with the contractually agreed boarding close time?

Most budget airlines pull this crap but I've started pushing back especially when it's poor weather outside and they expect us to wait in the rain just to improve their metrics

They need some EU261 denied boarding threats/claims to sort them out

reply
upvoteby ZeWaka20 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
Boarding is hard because it's at the discretion of the airlines, yeah. Departure time is easier because of https://www.fly.faa.gov/edct/showEDCT
reply
upvoteby exidy19 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
> Departure time is easier because of https://www.fly.faa.gov/edct/showEDCT

If you're in the US!

reply
upvoteby ZeWaka19 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
True. I think you'd have to scrape it from sites that expose it or pay for an API for a country like the UK.
reply
upvoteby zeroonetwothree17 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
Why is duration important? Surely you already knew what it was when you booked and it's not like it changes. I can't say that I've ever wanted to double check the duration of my flight.
reply
upvoteby friendzis15 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Knowing when I land, especially if there are any disturbances, is probably THE most important piece of information with regards to a flight. I have already planned my airport arrival, at least for the first leg, and the worst scenario is I have to stare at a screen/book for a bit longer. If the landing is delayed I might need to make amendments to the plans for the rest of the day.
reply
upvoteby fourwood9 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
The complaint is about the visibility of the flight duration (e.g. "this flight will take 1h 50m"), not the landing time (e.g. "this flight will land at 11:25am"). The landing time is prominently displayed in the flight info pane. Knowing your flight duration (gate-to-gate time) is not impacted whatsoever by flight delays, so I think you're conflating these two things inappropriately.
reply
upvoteby rconti17 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
I think the design is great; my only gripe is it's awful on the iPad mini. But so are Apple apps. They think it makes sense for the side drawer (in portrait mode) to cover half the screen. Which is especially insane in apps with maps where the drawer COVERS THE "YOU ARE HERE" DOT.
reply
upvoteby nemothekid17 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
>one of the most important pieces of data for a flight, its duration,

What is your use case for Flighty, and why would this information be important at all?

reply
upvoteby sneak3 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
I regularly fly all over the world, and it's nice to know how long my flights are going to be? I'm not always flying direct, and seeing the lengths of the legs and the lengths of the layovers allows me to plan my day and my sleep schedule.
reply
upvoteby oslem16 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
I use their widgets more than the app itself. They display the most important information I need well imo.
reply