Thanks, you're right. My "it is possible" is doing some heavy lifting there :). We've found theorems (stated in the paper) that carry through 64 rounds, so it is possible that theorems might carry through the full 128 rounds of double-SHA256. Bitcoin's proof-of-work is indeed a "partial second preimage", and constraints a certain number of leading zeros, i.e. a certain number of set bits. It's possible (there we go again) that this could leave enough wiggle room for large algabraic solvers like kissat to satisfy a large number of clauses about them. So far nobody is doing that, and ASICs are very simplistic. However, we are not making any claims about preimage attacks in this paper!
reply