upvote
>What type of developer chooses UX and performance over security? So reckless.

Initially I assumed this is sarcastic, but apparently not. UX and performance is what programmers are paid to do! Making sure UX is good is one of the most important things in programmer job.

While security is a moving target, a goal, something that can never be perfect, just "good enough" (if NSA wants to hack you, they will). You make it sound like installing third party packages is basically equivalent to a security hole, while in practice the risk is low, especially if you don't overdo it.

Wild to read extreme security views like that, while at the same time there are people here that run unconstrained AI agents with --dangerous-skip-confirm flags and see nothing wrong with it.

reply
Installing 3rd party packages the way Node and Python devs do regularly _is_ a security hole.
reply
We definitely agree on that. Fortunately some of the 600+ comments here include suggestions of what to do about it.
reply
Even more wild to read that sarcasm about "removing locks from doors for 87% speedup" is considered extreme...

And yes, we agree that running unconstrained AI agents with --dangerous-skip-confirm flags and seeing nothing wrong with it is insane. Kind of like just advertising for burglars to come open your doors for you before you get home - yeah, it's lots faster to get in (and to move about the house with all your stuff gone).

reply
Better developer UX can directly lead to better safety. "You are holding it wrong" is a frequent source of security bugs, and better UX reduces the ways you can hold it wrong, or at least makes you more likely to hold it the right way
reply
> Better developer UX can directly lead to better safety.

Depends. If you had to add to a Makefile for your dependencies, you sure as hell aren't going to add 5k dependencies manually just to get a function that does $FOO; you'd write it yourself.

Now, with AI in the mix, there's fewer and fewer reasons to use so many dependencies.

reply
Friction is helpful. Putting seatbelts on takes more time than just driving, but it’s way safer for the driver. Current dev practices increase speed, not safety.
reply
"Security" is often more about corporate CYA than improving my actual security as a user, and sometimes in opposition, and there is often blatant disregard for any UX concession at all. The most secure system is fully encrypted with all copies of the encryption key erased.
reply