upvote
I kinda remember a female friend ranting the 2013 game a long time ago, that the first half hour of it is essentially a non-interactive movie, in which Lara spends most of her time grunting and screaming while she gets banged up and falls off from ledges.

Watching the playthrough on youtube its not an unfair assessment:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcsVU70dI3s

reply
That part, and the player-death sequences(!), plus some other cutscene stuff, really weirded me out. It all read to me as way more sexualized (in a specific, fetishy sort of way) than anything in the old Tomb Raider games. Hated that aspect of it so much that I almost didn't even look at the sequels.

But I'm a dude, I dunno if it read that way to women who played it.

reply
The reboots are very much about growth -- she starts off as a scared teenager but grows into an unstoppable killing machine by the end. I could see them being less appealing to women though just because of the intense amount of violence in those games (as compared to the original ones)
reply
That's not growth, that's a regression. That is trauma and suffering.

Nathan Drake is similarly presented as a hero, but requires a deep psychopathic disconnect from reality to exist as a character.

reply
It's perplexing that strong female leads often end up just being more masculine.

Perfect Dark N64 commercial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAo7Vt4X_Ys

reply
My wife really disliked masculinization of the main character in the new She-Ra. The original was maybe her favorite cartoon as a kid, and what appealed was that She-Ra was a pretty, presenting-very-feminine princess who was also strong and kicked ass. She took the new representation (however it was intended, which, I think it's a safe bet it wasn't intended this way) as saying "being a strong woman means being more masculine and isn't compatible with the traditionally-feminine", which was very much not anything she was interested in.

In that specific case I think it was a result of the whole show bending almost every gender-presentation toward something less binary, on purpose, but the general tendency to make a woman character stronger simply by increasing her masculine presentation is pretty common and isn't well received by a lot of folks.

reply