You lose in versatility, then you can't add user-defined operators, which is pretty easy with a Pratt parser.
replyYou can have user-defined operators with plain old recursive descent.
replyConsider if you had functions called parse_user_ops_precedence_1, parse_user_ops_precedence_2, etc. These would simply take a table of user-defined operators as an argument (or reference some shared/global state), and participate in the same recursive callstack as all your other parsing functions.
With a couple of function pointers you can climb precedence with just functions:
reply parse_left_to_right(with(), is_token()) {
left = with()
while(is_token()) {
right = with()
left = operate(left, right, operator)
}
ret left;
}
p0() { ret lex digit or ident; };
p1() { ret parse_left_right(p0, is_mul); };
p2() { ret parse_left_right(p1, is_add); };