WiB is different from Move Fast and Break Things and again different from YAGNI though.
replyWiB doesn't mean the thing is worse, it means it does less. Claude Code interestingly does WAY more than something like Pi which is genuinely WiB.
Move Fast and Break Things comes from the assumption that if you capture a market quick enough you will then have time to fix things.
YAGNI is simply a reminder that not preparing for contingencies can result in a simpler code base since you're unlikely to use the contingencies.
The spaghetti that people are making fun of in Claude Code is none of these things except maybe Move Fast and Break Things.
VHS was not worse is better. It’s better is better.
replySpecifically, VHS had both longer recording times and cheaper VCRs (due to Matsushita’s liberal licensing) than Betamax did. Beta only had slightly better picture quality if you were willing to sacrifice recording length per tape. Most Betamax users adopted the βII format which lowered picture quality to VHS levels in order to squeeze more recording time onto the tape. At that point Betamax’s only advantage was a slightly more compact cassette.
replyAlso to correct another common myth, porn was widely available on both formats and was not the cause of VHS’s success over Betamax.
Betamax was arguably better.
replyNot in ways that the market cared about.
replyArguably better quality, but at the cost of being shorter. In the great trade off of time, size, and quality, I think VHS chose a better combination.
replyIt depends which definition of "better" you use. VHS won the adoption race, so it was better there. While Betamax may have been technologically superior, in hindsight we can say it apparently failed to address other key aspects of the technology adoption lifecycle.
replydeleted
reply