we may have not been able to replace bash yet, but the popularity of alternative shells that are not bash compatible is growing. besides nushell there are fish, elvish, murex, oils (also includes a bash compatible mode to help with the transition) and probably some others that i missed. i see more and more tooling support for some of these, which shows that usage of these shells is growing.

> very few user would really care about this difference

Oh the user absolutely does if that user creates lots of branches and the branches are stacked on top of each other.

I get your feeling though; sometimes in my own private repositories I don’t bother creating branches at all. Then in this case jj doesn’t really make much of a difference.

I may be reading too deeply but it sounds like you haven't even tried it. You should! Its really hard to live without it, once you feel it in your fingers.