upvote
We're supposed to be engineers. Criticising a concept based on conjecture and insult is unbecoming of our culture.
reply
> We're supposed to be engineers. Criticising a concept based on conjecture and insult is unbecoming of our culture.

The entire thing is nothing but conjecture. No real software has been produced by the concept to date, except more garbage software that takes hundreds of thousands of lines where a few thousand would do.

And to be clear, Beads and Gastown are unbecoming of our “culture” and any self respecting engineer would recoil in horror at the concept.

reply
How is it conjecture when you just admitted you're aware of a repo with hundreds of thousands of lines of code.

Your argument belies a lazyness or skill issue. You abandon the possibility of proof to sling mud.

People have made a shit ton of economic value with shit code over the course of history of software and now that's accelerating with this sort of shite. I appreciate its ugly but i will not follow you by fashioning a duvet out of arrogance and throwing rocks people investigating the ugly.

What they're doing it at least an interesting spectacle and ill wait for the show to end before writing my review.

reply
deleted
reply
What it means is that it is easy to shit on other people's work. Much harder to give constructive criticism - especially on what looks like a throwaway account.
reply
It’s not “other people’s work” because Steve didn’t do any work. He vibe coded hundreds of thousands of lines that don’t do what they’re supposed to with many thousands of lines of documentation that are inaccurate at best and aspirational at worst. He wrote some blog posts and got them picked up by vapid outlets that had nothing else to add to boost his exposure.

Case in point: no one talks about beads or gastown on HN because it’s crap that no one uses. Even *claw and that dumb fad get more mileage. meanwhile, CC vs Codex is an ever ongoing battle and Anthropic employees announce policy changes in “Tell HN” posts which stay on the front page for days.

reply