upvote
Political power is the bottleneck for most shit that matters, not computational power.

Most of the stuff that sucks on the us sucks because of entrenched institutions with perverse interests (health insurers, tax filing companies) and congressional paralysis, not computational bottlenecks. Raw intelligence is thus limited in what it can achieve.

reply
> Ascribing a lot of power to intelligence (which doesn't quite correspond to what we see in the world)

Which animal would you say has god-like power over all other animals?

reply
I don't think any of them do. Some organisms/viruses or groups of organisms could destroy humans more easily than humans could destroy them.

There's no doubt humans possess some powers (though certainly not godlike) that other organisms don't, but the distinction seems to be binary. E.g. the intelligence of dolphins, apes, and some birds doesn't seem to offer them any special control over other organisms (and it didn't even before humans arrived). So even if there could be such a thing as superhuman intelligence, I don't think it's reasonable to assume it could achieve control over humans (now superhuman charisma may be another matter).

reply
> Some organisms/viruses or groups of organisms could destroy humans more easily than humans could destroy them.

"Destruction" is only one power that could be a component of "godlike power". There are several more; like power of intentional selective breeding, power of species creation (also via intentional selective breeding), etc.

What about power of granting happiness or misery to large swathes of a species (chickens, anyone?)

reply
Do you consider viruses to be animals?
reply
fungus.

Oh, wait, that's not an animal. My bad.

reply
I don't agree with you. Lets assume intelligence is not what ascribes power but probably another thing. In your opinion, what would a superhuman be like? On what dimensions would they be better than us in?

Do you not agree that there could be entities more powerful than us?

reply