undefined

points

[-]

Now that's one fine No True Scotsman.

    A: GPUs use a lot of power!
    B: Not all of them are running 100% continuously, eh?,
    A: They waste too much power when they're idle, too!
    C: None of the H200s are sitting idle, you knob!

I mean, they are either wasting energy sitting idle or doing barely useful work. I don't know what to say anymore.

We'll cook ourselves, anyway. Why bother? Enjoy the sauna. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

by lxgr4 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

I'm not saying that this isn't "true idling", I'm saying that idling H200s simply don't exist, i.e., I disagree with B. Do you, A, even disagree?

> they are either wasting energy sitting idle or doing barely useful work

Now here's a true (inverse) scotsman, or more accurately, a moved goalpost: Work on things you don't deem valuable is basically the same thing as idling?

> We'll cook ourselves, anyway. Why bother? Enjoy the sauna. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I'm very concerned about that too, but I don't think we'll avoid the sauna with fatalism or logically unsound appeals to morality about resource consumption.