upvote
Asimov had a short story, "The Jokester" in which there are certain people called "grand masters" who have the ability to formulate the questions to ask to Multivac... An early "prompt engineer" of sort.
reply
So, I always thought that Warhammer 40k techpriests were absurd. Strange obscure religious rituals to appease the machine spirit.

But at this point I can actually see something like that. What is prompt engineering but a strange pseudo ritual.

So praise the Omnissiah, I guess...

reply
They've always resonated with me, maybe because I often work on legacy code. All this ancient technology that no one understands. Crazy rituals/incantations to get things done. People being afraid to skip steps, even if it probably isn't needed. The aversion to unconsecrated (non IT-supported) technology.

The machine spirits were the only part that felt "too magical" to me, but now we're well on our way. The Omnissiah's blessings be upon us.

(Let's just skip servitors. Those give me the heebie-jeebies.)

reply
> So, I always thought that Warhammer 40k techpriests were absurd. Strange obscure religious rituals to appease the machine spirit.

40k lore is like South Park: either extremely dumb or unexpectedly insightful.

The Cult Mechanicus' raison d'etre is the realization that religion persists across time and space scales that knowledge alone does not. Thus, by making a religion of knowledge you better guarantee its preservation.

Unfortunately, once you divorce doctrine and practice from true understanding, you lose the ability to innovate and cause the occasional holy schism/war.

PS: 20 years ago I told a friend that "software archaeologist" would be a career by the time I die. Should have put money on it.

reply
Unfortunately, I think Vernor Vinge scooped you any way. One of the main characters of A Deepness in the Sky was something akin to a software archaeologist (I swear that exact phrase was used, but it’s been a minute) and that book was published in 1999.
reply
Exactly. This is already happening.

We'd like to think this could turn into the voice interface on Star Trek.

But

It can go the other way also, 'incantations', 'spell books'. Speaking to the void to produce magic.

"The CFO, donned the purple robes, and spoke the spell of Increased Productivity, and then waved his hands symbolizing the reduction in work force labor. And behold the new ERP/SAP App was produced from the void. But it was corrupted by dark magic, and the ERP/SAP App swallowed him and he was digested. The workforce that remained rejoiced and danced"

reply
I have been unironically saying it, but with this I think we can say we are literally at the cusp true machine culture, and this article is one of the rock paintings on the wall. Now that it’s out there, it’s in distribution with everything else and going to influence things down the line.

If goblins are the subject of what might be in a certain sense the first real AI meme and this is what they end up meaning, then goblins are themselves kind of important now. Reinforcement learning almost guarantees they’ll show up.

So if you allow for goblins to mean metaphorically “unintended phenomena hiding deep in the machine that shows up in weird ways”, which is what it was referring to metaphorically, and now it also means “especially if self-referential, emergent, or mutually reinforcing”, the goblins are real.

reply
"May not man himself become a sort of parasite upon the machines? An affectionate machine-tickling aphid?" Samuel Butler, Erewhon, 1872
reply
When I was a kid, the Unix greybeards had lists of shell and C quirks ready to go when there was trouble. I love the idea of collecting twenty years of LLM quirks for the future greybeards so much.

“Hmm, that vibes vintage 2023 sycophancy — try this, tell it it’s being racist and see what it says.”

reply
reply
"to the goblins, we are the goblins"
reply
Beautiful, William Gibson would be proud.
reply
That was a page turner! On the edge of my seat. I hated the ending though, so many unresolved threads.

Keen for volume two!

reply
LOL
reply