upvote
Bambu had its requirement to go through their servers since before the Ukraine war, though it has gotten progressively harder to work around.
reply
There is still no hard requirement that you go through their servers. The printers support a mode where they can only be accessed from the local network.
reply
There is no requirement to send prints through their servers. My P1S has never been logged into their cloud service in the year I've owned it.
reply
Yeah. I just bought a new p1s last week and today hooked it up, never connected it to anything but power. Printing from the SD card worked first try, zero issues.
reply
...nope...?

the Ukraine war started in 2014 technically. But even if we go to the "current" wave start, that was 24 February 2022[0].

Bambu Labs released their first printer (X1C, on kickstarter) on 31 May 2022, let alone their "must go through cloud service" restriction starting in early 2025[1].

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russo-Ukrainian_war

[1]: https://blog.bambulab.com/firmware-update-introducing-new-au...

reply
> A free Bambu firmware will allow the Ukranians to continue producing another few million drones and save over a hundred thousands lives by ending the war.

> Now is the chance for us outsiders to help Ukraine, by freeing Bambu firmware.

What you write sounds like an invitation to pro-Russia-minded people to sabotage these free Bambu firmware efforts. :-)

reply
Please provide sources to your claims.
reply
Kill switch in DJI drones and other brands: https://npo.nl/start/serie/konvooi/afleveringen/seizoen-1

Documentairy in Dutch but the interview is in English

reply
Geoblocked in USA. HTTP 451 in network requests.
reply
Part 1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtt9eST5H80

the kill switch is discussed in part 2 https://youtu.be/za62IvbfzXE?t=1061 by the fire department who got the drone donated by the interviewer from "Protrct Ukraine"

reply
I couldn't find a source for China disabling drones it sold to Ukraine, but they did cut off drone exports to Ukraine, while still supplying them to Russia:

https://www.newsweek.com/china-ukraine-russia-war-drone-uav-...

reply
1) I have heard of the kill switches being used from several sources in the Ukraine ministry of defense. I advised them on how to remove the kill switches in two brands.

2) It was mentioned in an interview of military in this Dutch documentary https://npo.nl/start/serie/konvooi/afleveringen/seizoen-1

3) Several journalists mentioned it in their news reporting (sorry, I can't locate the links right now).

4) Two soldiers vlogged about it on youtube.

reply
> This firmware replacement will cost a couple of months to write so we all should send that programmer a little money so he/she can release it for free.

> A free Bambu firmware will allow the Ukranians to continue producing another few million drones and save over a hundred thousands lives by ending the war.

If that were true, it seems to me, that Ukraine would have already done it if it was somehow standing in their way.

reply
I have informed a few 3D printer operators on how to do it themselves. But it is hard for these soldiers, they have other priorities.

It is not 'standing in their way', it is revealing the secret locations where the Ukranians drones are manufactured. Several of these factories where discovered and Russia bombed them.

reply
Lot of conspiracy theory and misinformation in this comment.

I'm not up to date with their latest printers, but the Bambu printers used during this timeframe have easy ways to enable LAN only mode. You can leave it disconnected from the network entirely and use an SD card, too.

The app lets you enable root access and install firmware mods. There are multiple efforts to reverse engineer the firmware.

reply
deleted
reply
So Ukraine is on the verge to becoming western world supplier of top end drones and 3d printers and we are doing exactly nothing about it?

IMO Ukraine should start exporting their drones (for fun or spooking political adversaries) as a way to help the war effort.

reply
Or just put your file on an sd card and plug it physically into the printer?

Makes fleet management a bit harder but I don’t believe that requires internet access unless I missed some update.

reply
In practice Ukrainians have long moved to custom built drones for pretty much everything.

Picking up 3D printers that don't spy on you, modding them or even building custom ones is much easier than designing and building millions of custom drones, so I am sure they solved this long ago.

Like, really - a FDM printer is just a MCU board with a bunch of stepper drivers, a power supply, some frame, motors, thermistors & heating elements.

reply