Your opinion is that if, for a godforsaken reason, someone needs to rewrite URLs in their web server, they should avoid PCRE (something designed for string manipulation) because it's overkill, and they should use Lua (a full programming language) instead?

Am I understanding you correctly?

We do this for 3 sub-domains of ardour.org; there's no application code involved, because we're rewriting historical URLs to their current form, and the "application" doesn't do that or need to do that or need to know about that.