I have not read anyone claim that SynthID had a false alarm issue, so if it returned positive I would believe it is synthetic.
replyYou can trivially false-flag any image by uploading it to gemini and asking it to return it as-is
replyThat's not what the previous comment is referring to. They're referring to false positives, i.e "Gemini did not generate this (or process it) yet it says SynthID confirmed"
replySo imagine the damage you could do to an artist by having Gemini flag it then saying “see here’s the proof they’re using AI art!” That person would get eaten alive.
reply...except they can produce the same image without the fake SynthID.
replyit does have a false negative issue
replyAn issue this tool exacerbates. Labeling AI output is a good thing.
reply