upvote
I found the writing clear, concise, and human.
reply
It's certainly concise but I still remain unconvinced a human wrote it.

> It's a weapon disguised as helpfulness.

The source code is without a doubt AI (it's got a comment for the "<!-- Canonical URL -->"), so I guess one would have to assume they prepared the entire document beforehand, then fed it to Claude and instructed it to use that copy exactly.

...or they prompted "make me a site which tersely criticizes people who post AI slop on Slack, use the term slop grenade and style the site like nohello.net"

Eventually you just get a sense for these things.

reply
99% confident the article denouncing slop is itself slop.

Genuine AIDS. It'd be hilarious if it wasn't so terrifying and didn't happen with such regularity.

reply
All slopposters should get perma-lobotomized ^

Heres a sentence you will never have an ai say

reply
What makes you think this is AI slop?...
reply
> You asked a simple question. They lobbed a document.

> It's a weapon disguised as helpfulness.

These are particular sentences I find questionable. Would you write that way? I certainly wouldn't.

GPTZero is by no means perfect, but it agreed this was likely generated.

reply
> Would you write that way?

Well English is a foreign language for me, but yes I probably would, and then I'd get called out for being an AI haha

reply
We should instaban anyone who uses these patterns on ycombinator. If you talk like that for realsies, well too bad, try being more human and less linkedin next time
reply
Not the parent, but yes I would/do write that way for effect.
reply
Bro, do i got the bad news for you
reply
The heading " Why it's wrong" and the structure:

>Worse: it's a conversation killer. There's nothing to respond to. Your wall of text suppresses dialogue. They can't reply, can't push back, can't clarify. It's a weapon disguised as helpfulness.

This is slop. What it's saying is not even true, it's just punchy.

reply
Right, recent youtube solo lecture vlogs ripe with these clever punchy finishers. Annoying. I know people aren’t smart enough to actually be that witty ad hoc. Makes the whole thing feel fake af
reply