upvote
That data is not stolen. It's still there.
reply
Everytime something gets posted on HN about a bad or unfair state of affairs, some cynical nihilist posts “doh why r u surprised” and I’m sick and tired of it. These comments aren’t insightful, helpful or thought-provoking. You’re just helping a bad situation stay bad.
reply
My only imagined motivation for such posts is, “Look at me, I’m not surprised by this due to my superior intellect, why are you surprised?”

“No one is surprised, jackass, it’s just adults having a conversation about the current state of affairs.”

Yes, it’s tiring and rarely contributes positively to the conversation.

reply
[dead]
reply
> why do you think they'll stop

Because the sources are now polluted with AI. That's at least one reason they stop scraping.

reply
> You can't steal or profit off of that data, but it's fine for them for whatever reason.

The reason is quite simple. When Microsoft steals YOUR work, GDP go up. When YOU steal Microsoft's work, GDP go down. And the people who create and enforce our laws want GDP to go up. To these people morality and rights are a thin guise that can be conveniently discarded when it's invonvenient for them.

reply
> it's fine for them for whatever reason

the reason is crony capitalism. I wish I knew what the fix was

reply
[flagged]
reply
I paid tuition. The library bought its books. The theater sold me a ticket. Money changed hands every step, which is the part your analogy skips.
reply
Where did money change hands when you looked at a random image on DeviantArt and got inspired and made a similar image yourself?
reply
Most artists considered it a one to one exchange. They appreciated attribution and were flattered to inspire people. Some got gigs. Some got laid. The money flowed to DeviantArt, hosting providers, and ad providers. The artists were okay with this. They were the ones paying.

Then DeviantArt built a tool to automate the "make a similar image yourself" part and here we are. It removed all the fun parts: the personal contact, the attribution, the inspiration.

Artists realized they unwittingly contributed to the death of not only the community, but the art form they love. Lawsuits pending.

reply
Seriously. I recall a thousand hours of movies. Those memories sit in my head and I pay no royalties
reply
Put what you recall on paper, turn it into a screenplay. Let me know how quickly you get sued.
reply
Good artists copy, great artists steal.
reply
Trillion dollar companies license.
reply
One could argue most screenplays are derivative.
reply
Hollywood has extraordinarily well-defined controls for keeping things legal and everyone in the chain compensated. Plus a separate Oscars category for it.
reply
I heard somewhere there's like eight basic plots or something. and everything else is just an elaboration on that
reply
True, they live in your head rent free. But if you produce a derivative work, you have to pay.
reply