upvote

points

by coldtea11 hours ago |
comments
upvoteby nickpp11 hours ago|
[-]
State run (or heavily regulated) services around here in Eastern Europe: health care, education and housing. All incredibly bad and expensive, I pay huge chunks of my monthly salary for them and I try to avoid them at all costs. They get worse and more expensive with time too.

All the other services and products I use in my life, from the car I drive to the clothes on my back, the food I eat and the device I write this on are provided by private enterprise and they have become much better and cheaper in my life time.

reply
upvoteby yuriks10 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
Health care, education and housing have been getting worse and more expensive in the US over the decade also. Must be all that nationalization.
reply
upvoteby inglor_cz9 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
I can buy "more expensive", but as far as "worse", can you provide the relevant metrics?

I don't think that your chance of survival of a heart attack or lymphoma got worse since 2016.

reply
upvoteby yuriks9 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
I don't have concrete metrics/sources to give right now, but my general perception from reading the news is that there's been staffing issues pushing healthcare systems in the US towards increasing workloads in individual providers, leading to less time/attention given to individual patients, lower availability of appointment slots, and offloading of patients onto alternative app-based telehealth platforms, which have been trending up alongside aquisition/consolidation of independent private practices.
reply
upvoteby inglor_cz9 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Staffing problems are absolutely everywhere, regardless of the particular healthcare system or even political system. Czechia, the UK, China, Japan. It seems to be a global trend, much like falling birthrates.
reply
upvoteby yuriks8 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
I mean, yeah, that was the point of my original reply: health care, education and housing have been getting less accessible in general, not just that poster's country. (Or wherever they're from. I checked the comment history and it seems to be 90% talking back to people criticizing capitalism/markets. Wouldn't be my preferred hobby of choice, personally.)
reply
upvoteby nickpp5 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Not a hobby, but a duty. I lived under both systems and I do not wish the horrors I’ve seen in my youth onto my children. Although at this point, it’s probably unavoidable. It seems that some lessons can only be learned by experiencing them, no warning is ever enough: Russia, communism.
reply
upvoteby wing-_-nuts4 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Yes, now ask someone from a nordic country about how best to balance capitalism with regulation and social safety nets. I think you'd get a very different answer.
reply
upvoteby CamperBob22 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Step 1: start with a vast reservoir of oil revenue and a culturally-homogeneous population
reply
upvoteby wing-_-nuts1 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
I must have missed the fact that sweden, denmark, and finland had vast oil reserves. Also Sweden's population is now ~ 20% immigrants.
reply
upvoteby coldtea9 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
If you can afford less (lesser treatment, drugs, procedures, quality of doctors and hospitals you can pay for), then your chances of survival also got WAY worse.

Doesn't matter if the 1% has now access to better versions.

reply
upvoteby inglor_cz9 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Sure, if actual availability of healthcare to an average American has grown worse, that would be a bad result. But that is something you should demonstrate with data instead of just asserting it.
reply
upvoteby wing-_-nuts4 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
I mean one can go look at the health outcomes of the average american vs other developed nations, and see that we do not get much for the amount of money we spend. I won't bother to argue this with you. If you're genuinely operating in good faith, you're just as capable of finding the studies as I am, and if not, there's really no point
reply
upvoteby inglor_cz36 minutes ago|
parent|
[-]
When comparing average Americans and their health to average, say, Spaniards, we should not ignore the 400 lb gorilla in the room named "obesity".

Even Europeans are getting bigger, but America is way, way worse. Seeing those extreme landwhale-type people who cannot even walk around the mall and navigate it using a motorized cart, throwing bulk packages of horrible shitty ultraprocessed food and drinks into said cart, always makes me wonder how the hell is your healthcare system even capable of keeping them alive.

That is nothing short of a miracle, and should be taken into account in all international comparisons.

reply
upvoteby nickpp6 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
> Must be all that nationalization.

No, it’s the regulations. In less regulated, freer markets like vision correction eye surgery the costs went down and quality up. Even in health care.

reply
upvoteby wing-_-nuts4 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
You'll forgive me if perhaps I want something as important as eye surgery to be well regulated. Have a look at health outcomes for literally any industry where regulation is lax, like Brazilian plastic surgery. It's not great.
reply
upvoteby nickpp4 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Sure, I totally get you. Then higher costs, lower availability and crappier services (all due to less competition and more bureaucratic hoops) is a price you should be happily willing to pay.
reply
upvoteby wing-_-nuts4 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Contrasting the American Healthcare system vs one of pretty much any other developed economy proves this to be false.
reply
upvoteby coldtea9 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
State-run all those things used to be way cheaper and better here than after privatization. So much more, it's not even funny.
reply