upvote
Very sad to see Hacker News discussing science funding. This has nothing to do with the hacker ethos of maximizing corporate profit.
reply
Yeah it is as if this website is by a VC.
reply
you have strong opinions about this place for someone who joined less than 2 years ago... In my >13y active on HN I can tell you politics has always been present. It's just more likely for political topics to end up in flamewar, meaning they will get down ranked quickly. In general those stories don't stay long in the front page
reply
I have been here longer than you. I just rotate accounts after around 1000 karma (this account will be thrown away too soon)
reply
If that's the case how are you confused by the content in HN front-page?
reply
I am not confused. Sad. Go analyze the front pages for yourself with llm, it is becoming more political.
reply
Wouldn't it be great if our leadership wasn't so batshit crazy and we could just talk about the latest update to the coolest new framework?
reply
My Canadian girlfriend, who’s totally real, by the way, believes you.
reply
They've always had the final say on issuing grants, but it was handled by career scientists rather than political appointees. Canceling grants in process is extremely rare.

Since many of those grants concern science and tech it does seem relevant to this site.

reply
True, but that is democracy for you.
reply
It sure was.
reply
deleted
reply
I think Mike Masnick said it best here:

> " Why Techdirt Is Now A Democracy Blog (Whether We Like It Or Not)"

> ...but a few asked questions regarding what Techdirt is focused on these days, and how much we were leaning into covering “politics.”

> When the very institutions that made American innovation possible are being systematically dismantled, it’s not a “political” story anymore. It’s a story about whether the environment that enabled all the other stories we cover will continue to exist.

https://www.techdirt.com/2025/03/04/why-techdirt-is-now-a-de...

The current "Tech" culture, also traces its roots to people who very much didn't like the way things were done in corporate offices in places like NY.

Thats why Google used to have statements like do no evil, and it mattered to those early recruits. Things were built, with the intention to make things better for people.

The leaders of AI companies talk constantly about democracy and other values, while new CS grads are being told they will have no jobs.

For the record, I really wish HN was not as politically active. However this change is downstream of the environment.

reply
Places like HN don't necessarily become political of their own choice. Policy is forced on them, so they can no longer avoid it.
reply
> Also it really is sad to see “Hacker” News be “World News”. More Zig and less White House, please.

I have been on this website for 17 years (ugh that's scary), and people have been posting variations of this remark the entire time. It's a tiresome sort of post the thousandth time.

Politics have always been a consistent part of this website: it's a big part of the world that hackers live in, and barring rule enforcement to the contrary, hackers will always find politics interesting and want to talk about it.

If you want a website with a more narrow focus, there's always lobste.rs.

reply
I will take an invite
reply
Somewhat true. But as politics has accelerated to consume other interests, and HN has become disillusioned with startups it has gotten worse.

It illustrates to me how quickly everyone gets wrapped up in the current thing. There is no principle about which content is allowed or not. Entire threads representing alternative views are removed.

For example, In 2018 I remember you could not say a single thing critical of Elon or Tesla .

reply
deleted
reply