undefined

points

[-]

A) this court has a number of originalists, more likely to reject grabs for power than more progressive judges. There's worse things than a court that tries to adhere to the constitution when the executive branch and Congress both routinely do not.

B) do you really want to get to a place where the arbiters get politically reset and degraded every time the pendulum swings? This is the equivalent of a courtroom where a defendant or plaintiff can threaten to fire the judge or add their cousin as a co-judge.

by seanmcdirmid2 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

Ya, I think the only way out is to just split the country in two. The red states can go their own way without massive subsidies from the blue states.

by kristjansson1 hours ago|

parent|

prev|

[-]

Option C is, yknow, pass law (and ratify amendments) s.t. the interpretive power of the court is less of a factor

by harimau7771 hours ago|

parent|

prev|

[-]

As for B. Yes definitely. That's a massive improvement over letting the Republicans be the arbiters for the rest of our lives.

by jauntywundrkind2 hours ago|

parent|

prev|

[-]

I strongly recommend everyone listen & consider Jamelle Bouie's The Supreme Court is Corrupt. This is What We Can Do About It. https://youtu.be/hY279-A2fC4

The supreme court had a very limited role originally. And it's only by grants of Congress that they are allowed the staff, the ability to hear what cases they want to, and assorted other privileges. Beyond just packing the court, Congress could do a ton to rescind the power of these corrupt fiends who've gotten so far at tearing down the United States & gutting our nation, as they and their Leonard Leo/Federalist Society foes of America have lusted for for so long.

It's not just the Supreme Court either. Jamelle also effectively addresses so much of the incredibly vulgar court/judge shopping that makes a single judge North District of Texas such an incredibly popular and active venue, a political powerhouse that reliably will undo anything Federalist Society foes of America & government dislike. https://talkingpointsmemo.com/news/kacsmaryk-judge-shopping-...