upvote
Ha, thanks for sharing this!

I've been building Gemini live since before ChatGPT came out. I am so thrilled to see it actually helping people in the wild!

reply
Neat, but I'd bet it was "guessing" that rather than actually seeing it.
reply
If it’s “guessing” correctly 95% of the time, is that meaningfully different from “seeing” it for most practical purposes?
reply
I just mean that the image input probably didn't affect the output at all. Could have just told it "I'm an amateur doing bulbs and batteries and it doesn't work" and it would give the #1 search result on forums for that which is "did you strip your wire."

I feel like I'm in the audience at a magician show, except most of the audience is breathlessly amazed and doesn't understand how easily tricked they are.

reply
This really underscores how so much LLM "intelligence" is based off of people's experiences that they wrote about. It saddens me somewhat to see that it has basically all been captured by corporations now, and perhaps in a few years there will be little point in knowing things yourself simply because the LLMs will have gotten so good that there is no point to wasting the extra effort. Of course, this might lead to the atrophy of people's thinking muscles and a dumber and more subservient populace, but does anyone really care? Judging by the meteoric rise in the capabilities of LLMs over the past five years, is it really naïve to expect most knowledge work to be obsolete in the next ten?

The other stuff in this thread about decompiling firmware is a lot more interesting to me, though, seeing as it used to be a fairly demanding but rewarding task that has now been "solved" by Claude. It's a magic trick that is a lot harder to pull off than the other things in this thread.

reply
Yeah. I guess the redelegation of thinking from people to machines has been going on since before LLMs.

Today I got a haircut. At the cash register:

Hairstylist (early 20s): "That's $34. Would you like to leave a tip?"

Me: "Yes, please put an extra 20% on there"

Hairstylist: "Uuuhhhh... sorry, I don't have my phone. Can you google what 20% of $34 is for me?"

reply
Best comment I’ve seen today.
reply
deleted
reply