upvote
Sure. It's really about informed consent and acceptance of risk. I'm very conservative about that due to my background and business.

Say you have some flow that is processing/handling regulated, sensitive or other customer data with the LLM as part of an operational process. An example that I'm thinking of is for a customer who wants to more efficiently resolve or route IT incidents to the right place. The incident data may contain user-provided data has strings attached from a compliance perspective.

If you're using a third party API, your T&Cs are the only protection that you have. Microsoft/Google/Amazon are pretty decent by default. When I worked for the government, we had the leverage to extract much favorable terms from the big vendors like Google, Amazon, Microsoft as well. With Anthropic, and OpenAI, they are in the move fast and break things universe, you need to be bringing alot of money to the table to get terms changes, and you can easily stumble into a situation where they are retaining data in a manner that your customer will not like. So unless the customer is informed and accepting of that risk, proceed with caution.

I've had some success using self-hosted inference for these scenarios.

For development of software, totally different story -- it's your IP and you make the risk call.

reply
Oh man, thanks for taking the time to reply. I feel a bit better now, lol.

If you read my rant linked previously, yeah... we are on the same page. As another user pointed out in that thread, the issue here is that even on Bedrock and Azure Foundry, now with Fable 5, Anthropic inserts themselves as an additional data subprocessor that we would have to consider and certainly disclose, correct?

That kind of destroys the whole point of using Bedrock/Azure for the model, doesn't it?

reply
Yeah tbh I may have read past some of your previous post :) What you’re saying is what makes me nervous.

It was definitely sold as “anthropic IP, thorough your old pals at the hyper scaler”. And it’s turning into something else — I’m having lunch with AWS and this other guy showed up with them.

reply
No worries :) What this showed me is the power/velocity/inertia that Anthropic can hold over the 3rd party providers. Like, they should have pushed back on this, as it must have been clear to the 3rd parties that this change was a big deal to their customers... and yet, it went how Anthropic wanted it to go.
reply