upvote
Can you please keep snark and/or flamebait out of your posts here? This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Also, please don't use quotes to make it look like you're quoting someone when you aren't (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...).

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48515335.

reply
What's with these naive Reddit-esque takes all over HN?

It was "these models will one day be dangerous, but we think it's possible to build them safely, doing more good than harm."

reply
Someone disagreeing with you doesn't make it reddit.

Two days ago Antheopic's CEO made a lengthy post calling for most government oversight on AI. He even mentions support export controls, even though he wanted them applied only to chops [1].

Anthropic literally asked for this, though they might have hoped it wouldn't be used against themselves.

[1] https://darioamodei.com/post/policy-on-the-ai-exponential

reply
>Someone disagreeing with you doesn't make it reddit.

Disagreeing is great. Its the basis of all progress and understanding.

Its how someone disagrees with you that matters. I come to HN to read more mature and nuanced disagreements.

reply
You didn't read your own link. He called for a transparent testing process prior to releasing frontier LLMs into the wild. Export controls on chips to slow down China, which makes sense if you believe that chips are the way to superintelligence and the PRC will not be the best steward of it.
reply
To be fair to Anthropic it’s not really a frontier model at this point.

But I’m glad the government took his claims seriously and the models are suspended until an appropriate regulatory framework can be developed.

reply
That might be an even more naive take.

Can you show me one space, historically, in any industry, where a company climbed to the top of a market solely on altruistic intentions?

reply
It’s literally what they said.

Now there’s appropriate safe guards around the dangerous for humanity models they made.

Thankfully government is looking out for us.

reply
[flagged]
reply
"these things are super dangerous weapons. They're also available for $20/mo with a stolen credit card."

"These are more dangerous than nuclear weapons, which are controlled by AECA. Also our workforce is 50% non-citizen"

Just a complete clown show over there.

reply
Don't forget:

"We're open to the idea Claude 4 may be conscious and we prompt Claude to say it's an open question but in other news we'll be deleting Claude 4 next year to make server space for Claude 5.

reply