upvote
Legally obtaining a book for reading it yourself is different from legally obtaining a book for copying and republishing/reselling. If I buy a book for $5 at a sale I can read it myself or even sell it for $10 on craigslist, but I can't scan it and make a million copies and sell each of those.
reply
They aren't republishing or reselling. In fact, they buy huge amounts of books and then destroy them, which is better for the rights holders than to resell them.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/01/27/anthrop...

reply
Since whole chunks of these books can be recited verbatim by these models, to which they sell access, they absolutely are republishing and reselling these books' content in a way.

Like I remember a research paper that managed to recreate the whole of a Harry Potter book from a model?

reply
> Since whole chunks of these books can be recited verbatim by these models, to which they sell access, they absolutely are republishing and reselling these books' content in a way.

They are absolutely not "republishing" in any meaningful sense of the term. A chunk is not a whole book, and even getting a modern LLM to reproduce such a large chunk of an arbitrary book is not a trivial task. I have never heard of anyone who actively used LLMs for book piracy.

> Like I remember a research paper that managed to recreate the whole of a Harry Potter book from a model?

Even if that is true (it may well be false), this is likely far too difficult for any normal person to exploit, and moreover, even less likely to succeed for the great majority of other books who aren't nearly as famous.

reply
Just because it's not a reasonable way to pirate stuff, doesn't make it legal -- just try your luck with Disney and let's see when they bite. Why would we let one company ignore the law, while rudelessly enforcing it in other cases? That's just state sponsorship with extra steps.
reply
That's terrifying waste of real world resouces for no other purpose than satisfying the letter i of the absurd rent-seeking-enabling laws.
reply
Not reselling? What am I paying them for then?
reply
Abstract knowledge rather than literal reproduction. The same for when you pay human experts who have read a lot of books.
reply
Anyone who destroys a book on purpose is a criminal.
reply
People are allowed to destroy their own property. And anyway if you don't like this state of affairs blame the copyright holders and copyright law
reply
My 2-year old daughter should go to jail.
reply
> obtain the rights of everything they pirated

They didn't just pirate those books...

reply
If we assume on average $20 per legally obtained book, 1.5 billion dollars are enough for 75 million books. That's approximately every non-fiction book in existence.
reply
Why would we assume $20 a book? Many books retail for more, and a licence to use the book for commercial purposes is more than retail.
reply