upvote
This is wrong, given only the text of the article. The two books explicitly listed are not banned in Portugal or anywhere else. They are simply not subsidized with public money in some libraries.
reply
That makes more sense. How could a library or a bookshop in a location legally offer books that are banned in that location?
reply
THAT would be awesome bravery and freedom: "Come and take it" has been powerful before.
reply
I don't know the law in Portugal but I will assume the principles are similar to other western European countries.

If you have book that are actually banned in these countries, I don't think many people will call it awesome.

Books are typically banned for:

- copyright: not really a ban, but the copyright holder simply doesn't want it to be published the way you want it to be, doing it anyway is just piracy. It can be seen as "brave" if the copyright owner is an asshole, but doing that to authors you support is not great.

- hate speech: Germany for instance bans most Nazi stuff, whether or not it is a good thing is debatable, but in any case, what do you think the political message would be if you opened a Nazi library. Most other European countries have similar laws to some degree.

- porn: Need I say more? Special mention to child porn, which is super-banned, and definitely not awesome.

- libel: some people hide behind defamation laws to avoid criticism, but in most cases, these are actual lies and you don't want that.

I don't know of any banned book in Europe that anyone "woke" (for a lack of a better term) would want to put forward.

reply
"I don't want to share a book that the government has actually banned" is quite a position on this thread.
reply
deleted
reply
> Most other European countries have similar laws to some degree.

Except for historical or drama purposes. In the Basque Country you could buy tons of books about Nazis, Franco, ETA and whatnot.

reply
The first "Molon labe" famously did not go well.
reply
oh, i would say it went quite well:

>The main source for the events of the battle is Herodotus. According to his account, the Spartans held Thermopylae for three days, and although ultimately defeated, they inflicted serious damage on the Persian army. Most importantly, this delayed the Persians' progress to Athens, providing sufficient time for the city's evacuation to the island of Salamis.

>Though a tactical defeat, Thermopylae served as a strategic and moral victory, inspiring the Greek forces to defeat the Persians at the Battle of Salamis later the same year and the Battle of Plataea one year later.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molon_labe

reply
Historically (and maybe still today, in some very authoritarian countries!) university libraries were often this.
reply
As someone who lived under an authoritarian regime for more than 2 decades: that's not even close to be true.

Even discussing a taboo topic may cost someone their freedom, if not their life.

reply