upvote
To be fair, AI is also a very alluring tar pit for the technical.
reply
Philosophers were discussing that question far before LLMs were around.
reply
deleted
reply
Sure, but is there any evidence that psychology and for that matter, any animal intelligence, is anything more than linear algebra?
reply
I think the main problem is whether intelligence is a computable function (or at least approximable by ones, like AIXI is), and then whether it's of the form that NNs implement (linear algebras plus sigmoids and all that jazz).
reply
I think it should be shown that intelligence is linear algebra. Not that it's not linear algebra. Russell's teapot etc.
reply
> In summary, AI has tricked a bunch of philosophy majors ...

OTOH, their bank accounts is likely not complaining very loudly

reply
That's not actually the part that bothers me, but it's good to caution about envy.
reply
The reality is it would be a very small % of philosophy majors or the philosophically interested who would be able to shape their approach or personal opinions to match what the AI labs are looking for anyways.

Only particular schools / kinds of philosophy need apply.

I'm a (dropout) philosophy major, but for 30 years (last month!) have been doing SWE instead. The tar pit of being able to use my brain to make money instead of navigating politics inside academia... happened for most of us a long time before AI.

reply
>> The tar pit of being able to use my brain to make money instead of navigating politics inside academia... happened for most of us a long time before AI.

Anecdotal evidence to support your point.

Have a degree in Anthropology. Took copious amounts of philosophy classes as part of my major. Took some CS classes just to stay on top of the stuff happening in tech.

I wasn't able do what I wanted in Anthropology, so I took the same route and ended up in SWE. To a degree, I have monetized my degree because everything I learned while obtaining my degree I use almost every day in SWE. I was jaded by the toxic politics of academia and it finally pushed me out as well.

reply
Good news, you can become jaded by the toxic politics of corporate software development now, too!

When I worked at Google it was the thing that drove me nuts the most. It was very much a "publish or perish" kind of environment with performance and evaluation structures very obviously inspired by academia. (And just like academia, there was sometimes a culture of stealing other people's projects to get credit, with credit and kudos more important than any kind of monetary success since the company was run by an absolute firehose of revenue anyways... )

reply
The strange part is that they seemed to have tricked AI companies too.
reply
deleted
reply