upvote
So the problem with the Model 1 that the mixing cable is trying to solve is that the expansion port on that model has audio input pins, but no audio output pins. Now strictly speaking, this is sufficient if you just want to use the MD1's headphone jack (stereo) or A/V out (mono), but in addition to the analog audio circuitry not being amazing (though honestly the MD1 is much better than the MD2 here in general) it also imposes a fairly aggressive low-pass filter. This is rather undesirable for 44.1 kHz CDDA. As you note, the mixing cable allows the RCA outputs to be mixed on the CD hardware side which works around this issue.

On the MD2, they added audio output pins to the expansion port in addition to the existing audio input pins. This allows them to achieve the same effect with no mixing cable.

reply
> I think the article is sorta wrong about the sound setup, the Mega Drive I does have a sound input on the expansion port, and mixes it into its sound output.

The Megadrive has a stereo sound input on the cartridge port too, for a total of 3 stereo sound sources (the YM2612, the MegaCD, the cartridge) plus one mono source (the SN76489 PSG).

As far as I know no original release ever used the cartridge input, but nowadays it is supported by many flashcarts to emulate the MegaCD or to provide CD quality audio tracks (MSU-MD and MD+ romhacks), and it has been used by some recent games.

reply
The 32X used the cartridge audio input for its PWM audio channels. For one example of how this worked, Knuckles' Chaotix used the extra channels for the percussion in its music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6BSQVK9gSc
reply
The Sega CD manual says that the RCA jacks are for connecting the Sega CD to a stereo system or stereo TV. I guess they found that doing the sound mixing on the Sega CD made the output cleaner which would have been useful for people wanting to use it as a CD player instead of just for games. The mixing cable is necessary to use the RCA jacks on the Genesis 1 because the system does not have a sound OUTPUT on the expansion connector, only a sound INPUT. The Genesis 2 repurposed a couple of previously unused expansion pins as sound outputs, which let the model 2 Sega CD do the audio mixing without needing a patch cable.
reply