upvote
Plenty of companies use generic words for their name, and they still get trademarks.

American Airlines for example is indeed just an American airline. The Container Store, Vision Center, General Motors, International business machines (IBM), the list goes on.

Even Microsoft is just a contraction of their original product, microcomputer software.

reply
I understood it more in the line of preventing a company from naming itself "Low sugar" and then blocking other companies from adding the words "Low sugar" to their packaging. Same thing with OpenAI, another company should be free to create an AI that's fully open and tag it as "Open AI" without fearing legal problems with OpenAI.
reply
> Even Microsoft is just a contraction of their original product, microcomputer software.

Hopefully that was also a family suggestion because I can't think of a more sloppy name than "Microcomputer software"

reply
In the US
reply
Many of these companies have EU trademarks as well.
reply
Give me a break. Apple doesn't sell apples.
reply
Exactly. Apple can register Apple because they don't sell apples so it's not misleading. OpenAI can't register OpenAI because they make ai but it's not open. They could call themselves Peaches, OpenWombat or ClosedAI and there wouldn't be any issues because those wouldn't be misleading.
reply
> OpenAI can't register OpenAI because they make ai but it's not open

That's not the reason they can't. They can't register the trademark because it's a descriptive one.

If I try to trademark "hacker forum", an EU trademark officer will reject it not because my website doesn't have hackers on it, but because it's descriptive and prevents others from starting hacker forums.

So

> They could call themselves... ClosedAI

is also incorrect, because it's descriptive as well.

reply
>OpenAI can't register OpenAI because they make ai but it's not open.

Not the issue. Per the ruling even if their AI was open they still couldn't have the trademark.

reply
Open could mean open to integration (API), or opens your mind, or opens possibilities.
reply
No, the opinion doesn't have to do with whether OpenAI is open.
reply
deleted
reply
Do they have a trademark on the word apple with no other context? I thought it was Apple computer, which is distinct.
reply
Apple is also a record label (that existed before the computer company), specifically one owned by the Beatles.

There were even some legal battles between them, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Corps_v_Apple_Computer

Apparently it ended with Apple Computers buying the trademark from Apple (record company) and then licencing it back (weird but ok).

reply
It's like you are starting to get it.
reply