upvote

points

by Wowfunhappy4 hours ago |
comments
upvoteby drdexebtjl3 hours ago|
next
[-]
The problem with Undo reverting the clipboard state is that Undo is usually file or app-local, but the clipboard is shared. You can cut from app A, switch to app B, cut something else from app B, then go back to app A and undo the cut.

“Ghost cut” can work across apps with reasonable undo support by not using the clipboard at all and some form of IPC instead. For example, when you cut from app B before resolving the cut from app A, app A could be notified to cancel its cut.

I think this is much less intuitive than the current convention though.

reply
upvoteby Wowfunhappy3 hours ago|
parent|
next
[-]
> You can cut from app A, switch to app B, cut something else from app B, then go back to app A and undo the cut.

...right, thanks. So you could still make it work but you'd definitely need OS support, it's not something one app can fix.

Edit: You could make this work on an app level by checking if the contents of the user's clipboard is still the value they cut. If yes, revert to whatever clipboard contents you saved prior to the cut. Otherwise do nothing.

It's probably too much hidden behavior to be a good idea, but I think it would match what the user wants in 99% of cases.

reply
upvoteby drdexebtjl2 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
What would be in the clipboard after the undo in that scenario?

edit: Yeah, the problem is that the user does not expect undo to do something different depending on what they did on a different program.

Undo doing nothing to the clipboard always is more consistent and the better UX.

reply
upvoteby Wowfunhappy2 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
...yeah. But I still think these problems apply to Ghost Cut too. Unless the idea is that Ghost Cut only works within one app and/or the content lives in a special ghostboard separate from the clipboard, which I think is equally bad UX.
reply
upvoteby 0gs3 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
next
[-]
wow OS-level undo would be a way cooler solution to this problem
reply
upvoteby 3 hours ago|
parent|
prev|
[-]
deleted
reply
upvoteby justsomehnguy3 hours ago|
prev|
[-]
Even if it was 2GB of some data? Even if you run low on memory?

TFA and comments are clearly a solution is search of the problem.

reply
upvoteby Wowfunhappy2 hours ago|
parent|
[-]
Is it possible to copy 2GB of data to the clipboard? If it's an image or something I'd expect the clipboard to contain a reference to the image or some such. How do clipboard managers handle this?
reply