upvote
Why would you factor in salary unless they had to baby it through. You would only count the hours for setting up the harness and prompt and checking the result.

Training the model is going to be amortized over other uses.

reply
> Why would you factor in salary

Say that it turned out that the total cost of the proof of the Erdős unit-distance conjecture was $50 million.

Then the question really becomes: yes, these models are capable of proving important mathematical results, but at a very high cost. Is it worth it?

If a mathematician applied for a research grant of $50M USD for proving the same thing, they would have been laughed out of the bank.

What's more is that when you have a research grant, you train PhDs and postdocs, you hire new staff, and you disseminate. That is, you get much more value for the money spent.

I'm just curious what the cost is.

reply
It feels like the real cost might be negative though.. They use frontier math as a way to test improvements in their model. So solving the problems is like a positive externality, but the important thing is they can verify that the model is improving instead of looking at useless benchmarks. Plus it is good for marketing and attracting talent.
reply
I didn't argue that knowing the total cost is uninteresting. What I was saying is that realistically the total cost is:

Hours needed for prompt + Hours needed to check result + API costs.

You don't say "well let's add together the total yearly compensation of all the engineers and mathematicians at OpenAI that were involved" and throw that into the total cost. That's simply nonsense accounting.

The actual comparison you are making is some university researcher weighing between getting a grad student (several tens of thousands of dollars) vs typing up a prompt and sending a request to OpenAI for inference (as mentioned in the article, around $2000 in API and maybe a few hours for the prompt and harness).

reply
[dead]
reply
> The cost of generating the proofs for all 10 of these breakthroughs combined was under $2,000 at Sol API prices.

https://x.com/polynoamial/status/2083470822258467194

reply
Yeah sure but they didn't just throw a 5 year old at an LLM with $2,000. If you want good math results from LLMs you need to have math PhDs.
reply
That's clearly just for the tokens, this doesn't really answer OP's question.
reply
Given that OpenAI pays their employees with stock surely a breathtaking number, but not a very meaningful number now that the infrastructure is in place and the models are trained. AI could never get better and it would still be incredibly disruptive.
reply