upvote
Actually the purpose was not to invade our privacy as much, which we do and there is active lobbying (for example by Google) against any better solution: https://noyb.eu/en/eu-member-states-and-google-suddenly-want...
reply
Classic over-regulation producing unintended side effects
reply
Really?

Because the industry really respected DNT[0]?

Regulations are needed when the kids cannot play nice in the school yard.

GDPR is actually not that bad if you read it rather than subscribing to much of the malicious compliance we see.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track

reply
Nah fuck the companies and their horse shit.

99% percent of them intentionally turn the "decline" choice into a 5 - 10 step game of dark patterns even though the EU policy says it should be equally easy to decline. They know its bullshit but they also know the chance that someone will drag them through court is low.

reply
I’ve long believed that making companies liable for paying damages if PII is leaked in a data breach would be the best way to stop excessive tracking. If you force them to have to manage user data like they’re handling radioactive waste then the expense and overhead involved is a natural drag on the business logic that drives the bottomless appetite for data collection. They’ll collect it if they actually need it, and they’ll take great pains to secure it.
reply
Actually having worked in big companies,many of them just track everything, but don’t actually use the data, which is even worse.
reply
That’s already part of the EU regulations people in the comments complain about
reply
The most valuable data breach content isn’t your advertising tracking data, though.

It would be your payment information, which is orthogonal to most of the tracking data.

The black market demand for leaked advertising-related tracking data is basically nil, except maybe in cases where it’s related to something else exploitable or usable for blackmail like if someone frequents cryptocurrency exchanges or porn sites. Nobody cares to pay for black market data about you shopping for towels on Amazon or things like that.

reply
[dead]
reply