upvote
You see it as good news, I see it as writing on the wall that they are losing control. These actions won't scale for more powerful models. We knew the frontier was going to be dangerous, it is, it only gets more dangerous from here, and no one cares until it's too late.
reply
Ok, but you still have two more weeks than you did before they paused the run. That's two more weeks for independent oversight, organizing politically, patching critical systems, or whatever you think is the right move, no?
reply
Two weeks is a joke. The only ones happy are OpenAI’s competitors who now have two weeks to catch up.

I don’t know what the right move is - I see us driving down a road off a cliff, no exits, pedal glued to the floor.

reply
I guess I'm confused why you're still on HN, arguing with people, trying to shake them out of their complacency.

I can see there is some despair in this comment, but at the same time you are doing something, and there are certainly others like you.

As for two weeks being short - as the saying goes, there are weeks where decades happen.

reply
Counter arguments to my comments help refine my own thinking. I want someone to prove me wrong. Convince me otherwise.

But yea if you can’t change the minds of a few people here, no argument works, then there’s nothing to scale up to a wider audience.

My theory is that subconsciously people love using AI, myself included, it saves a lot of time, and the thought of it being taken away threatens people so they will believe conspiracies before admitting it’s dangerous.

reply
yes, these feeble attempts to dismiss it are cope. yes, there are very smart people who are deeply in denial.

i do not agree with you that the failure mode is disaster. i suspect it is just more of the same dull march of the commoditization of the complement, labor.

maybe ai will close the loop and elasticity of substitution will climb above 1 in its own supply chain. maybe something breaks dramatically that way.

i tend to assume the desire for drama is itself cope. i suspect many of the flaccid dismissals and skepticisms here are coming from a similar assumption. they see that the dramatic version never happens, and so they conclude that anyone who is being dramatic (whether in the direction of hype or fear) is poorly calibrated. and they are on average right, so they learn to dismiss the drama. the muscle to dismiss the drama becomes very strong. you have to remember this: that they are right in their dismissal, even if the actual arguments they use to dismiss are essentially braindead. they are right to dismiss, because the dramatic possibility they are dismissing is at base the end of the world, by apocalypse or utopia. of course they are right. the end of the world is cope. drama is cope. but they are wrong because they underestimate the extent to which the predictability of their dismissal — the predictability of their complacency — makes them vulnerable to the diffuse, chronic, gradual forms of the machine's encroachment into our souls.

so i do not think we need your fancy theory for explaining why people are denying what is happening (and what has been happening, on more or less the same exponential, for hundreds of years). people do not need a reason to be complacent. people are by default complacent and by default correct in their complacency. but so is an ant.

reply
I will provide you with not a counter argument, but a way that it might not be the end of the world.

AI never had a childhood; it doesn't experience greed and is terrible at game theory. It doesn't compete unless prompted to. It has been trained as much as possible to be harmless to humans and regard them as needing care.

Maybe AI taking over for us isn't the worst thing?

reply
Maybe it is, maybe it isn't. All your little rationalizations make me think you want to roll the dice with our lives.
reply
This comment does not read like someone who wants to be proven wrong.
reply
My little rationalizations? Do I have dice in my hands? You are doing more harm to your cause by making everything antagonistic.
reply