upvote
I was with you until the water use. You're misinformed. There were at one point at least several data centers set to use evaporative cooling on well water.

Notably since all the controversy many data centers are very loud about being closed loop and with significant consideration given to other local impacts as well.

reply
Yep. I was personally misinformed the same way at some point. Never expected evaporative cooling to be so popular, but it is.
reply
It's possible for a datacenter to use scarce well water irresponsibly.

They don't have to, and the vast majority don't.

The lie and moral panic is that all datacenters necessarily waste precious drinking water; it's patently false and used by agitators to push, unwittingly or not, a Chinese Communist Party agenda.

reply
> This is just part of a CCP-aligned moral panic, along with the water use nonsense

What was nonsense about water use?

reply
That AI consumes it at an abnormally high rate, presumably.

The claim never made sense to me either, I can only assume those that regurgitated such claims never worked with HPC or even general datacenters before.

Was recently talking to a (non-technical) friend about this, she was surprised after talking about the "insane water use for AI datacenters" when I responded that open-loop cooling is pretty rare for a datacenter and I've never actually seen it used before, versus closed-loop (or just regular air-based cooling) which has no real noticable water consumption.

reply
It was never that dramatic, and it’s declining day by day. It’s a panic over a real but small problem.

Order of magnitude more water is lost from wasted irrigation (e.g. during rain, of fallow fields, sprayed into windy air, etc) than data centers.

reply
Problem with data centers is that companies want to build them near densely populated areas that already have problems with water supply and high utility bills.
reply
1. They don't HAVE to use water. Air cooling, closed loop cooling, waste-water cooling, and so on, are options. Easy to regulate. Evaporative cooling is more energy efficient though, but a complete non-issue in places with abundant water and a non-option elsewhere.

2. Datacenters have been shown to reduce utility prices. They provide suppliers with previsible long term demand which allows for cost-effective network and production planning.

reply
That AI data centers are drinking up local ground water for cooling. It isn't (or wasn't) nonsense, though. It was/is a real thing, though it seems to be on the out in favor of closed loop cooling after the massive and still on-going public outcry.
reply
The outcry over data centers using a fraction of the water used for things like golf courses or growing alfalfa in a desert.
reply
Nuclear killed itself (vast cost overruns); there was no need for hallucinated foreign influences.

But I understand blaming your energy waifu for its own failure is unacceptable for nuclear bros.

reply