undefined

points

[-]

You are mistaken. I'm running Qwen 3.7 28B 4bit (MLX) with a 200k context window and everything total is 32GB RSS.

Is this the best? No. That's why I said the sweet spot. Getting from 16GB macs to 32GB is perhaps possible. Jumping to 64GB or 128GB as the default is simply unreasonable right now.

by e28eta11 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

I have a similar machine, and briefly poked at running a local LLM, but got discouraged after a couple days. The quality, responsiveness, and impact on the rest of the system didn’t seem worth it to me.

What sorts of things are you doing with the local LLM? Anything interactive? Should I take another look?

by Xeoncross9 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

Yes, 15-30 t/sec is pretty slow for local models so I recommend running local LLM tasks overnight where (vs paid plans) there isn't a risk of chewing through your token budget from a rogue loop or sub-agent. Even if it takes hours, you're sleeping anyway so no concern. herdr + pi works great for this but there are lots of harnesses.

by Foobar856811 hours ago|

parent|

prev|

[-]

Memory used : 38GB, and I haven't even started a LLM nor podman, I always fight with memory when using LLM on my mac with 48gb.

And I don't remember to have been able to have pushed to 200k context Qwen 3.6. 3.8 is running on my RTX 5090.

by redox9910 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

Qwen 27B runs very comfortably on a 5090. You need to use Q4 quants and Q8 KV cache. Here's the math

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49514141

by tristor11 hours ago|

parent|

prev|

[-]

I assume you mean Qwen 3.8-27B? Yes, you can run this in 32GB of RAM, but it's very context limited. With KV cache compression and other techniques, it's better now than in the past, but I'd still want more RAM, personally.

EDIT to add that you need to reserve 8GB for the system if you don't want to cause problems on macOS, which means 32GB RAM = 24GB max for model + context. It takes 18-19GB to load a 4-bit quant of Qwen3.8-27B, so I'd be really surprised if you can actually get a 200k context window. You need to fit within a 24GB WSS (which is generally a more constrained RSS) to get stable performance on 32GB RAM.

by jckahn9 hours ago|

parent|

[-]

I run Qwen 3.8 27B just fine on my Mac mini M4 24GB. I use Unsloth's Q3 XXS with 128k context. It successfully completes long horizon tasks with OpenCode.