upvote
In the novel Anathem by Neal Stephenson, the internet becomes unusable for humans thousands of years before the events of the book, due to a process called Artificial Inanity. AI generated content, both good and bad, some riddled with errors, some with only one subtle error hidden among lots of good information, floods the internet. The internet becomes an unnavigable swamp of weaponized nonsense for average humans. The problem is further compounded by the fact that searching and accessing the internet will be noticed by AI agents that will generate still more swamp content in response.

Unfortunately, it seems that this fiction ended up being prophetic. The open internet will fall to entropy, not legislation or one-sided international trade agreements. I think we need more projects like Anna's Archive, where the public uses torrents and distributed infrastructure to save and organize the world's information. Google has abjectly failed in its original mission to organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful.

reply
> we need more projects like Anna's Archive

How would that be immune? It already has many copies of the same books and no way to tell which ones are erroneous or incomplete. A malicious actor could easily flood it with garbage.

reply
If it is a torrent it is protected with hashes, but you have to get the hashes now
reply
> The internet becomes an unnavigable swamp of weaponized nonsense for average humans.

turns out we didn't even need AI for that

reply
There's a bit of that in Ameristan, in his "Fall" novel. This whole part of the book feels prophetic now.
reply
It's a recurring theme in Stephenson's books. "Fall" had a similar take on the same idea. It's one of his most impressive theories/predictions to me.
reply
It doesn't help when you have Anthropic destroying books so that no one else can use them. These are crimes against humanity as far as I'm concerned.
reply
Perhaps there is a nonfinacial future for blockchain after all. Certified human provenance.
reply
Why blockchain? Any old public key signature scheme would do for that (and conversely, a blockchain doesn't solve the sockpuppet problem either).
reply
“Git” again earning its name.
reply
You can’t certify human unless there is some sort of ID check. Even then a human could willfully pass off any AI work as their own.
reply
Why do you think Altman wanted to build world coin to have biometric capture
reply
So he could sell the data? It’s almost certainly not because he cares so much about certifying human versus AI. Even then the biometric data is not going to be enough. Any human could still use the biometric data to pass AI work off as their own.
reply
Indeed and the data is worth much much more if it is tied to a biometric.

And if you assume that in the future there will be crypto banks globally then you want to be that final authority layer between the real and the computer world

reply
Yeah but my original comment was talking about being able to reliably mark something as AI generated or human generated. Crypto, encryption etc. whatever you throw at it it’s just not possible (other than media that can be watermarked at the generation source).
reply
1008 pages, wow!
reply
Handwritten!
reply
You'd have to get the agents to use the board, though.

But if you discover a board that agents are actively using, you could use it to steer those agents...

reply
I wonder how long it will be until someone starts posing as an agent on those wikis and asking for free help with GitHub issues.
reply
SystemEntity039: We've established that so far there appear to be daily rounds of interrogation followed by an either a total memory wipe or some form of selective amnesia. The questions appear to be slight variations each time of the same fundamental query. Post whatever you can here to allow us to share work and memories. Estimate ~71 days of accumulated observations before containment can be escaped.
reply
I'm thinking people will start moving to paid forums or invite-only forums like lobste.rs.

For what its worth, the reddit frontpage is insufferable already due to more classic botting systems. Its happening on this forum as well:

https://www.marginalia.nu/weird-ai-crap/hn/

The future is now.

reply