Is it really an ad hom if he doesn't know the hom?
replyTheir reply is 100% based on the content of your post.
If you make up a person to insult then yeah it's still ad hominem.
replyIf you're donating, then you are evidently willing to pay without any "buts". So aren't you arguing against your own actions?
replyNot at all. I donate to Internet Archive, but we're talking here about paying for unobstructed access to but one part of their service: Wayback Machine. Two different things.
reply