upvote
Show HN: A competition for small neural networks that play strategy games

(tinybrains.dev)

15yrs back I participated in "Google Ants AI Challenge 2011", an ai programming competition, hosted by the University of Waterloo, and I ranked #127 (#1 in my country). The competition gave me a huge learning oppurtunity where developers across the world came to a forum and discussed various techniques.

Now, I've built a similar platform to bring back the fun of building a small neural network that can play the game well. Neural Network optimization seems to be much more fun.

Plz share your feedback to improve the platform and add more games.

reply
Nice work, the new site looks great.

Can you give more background on the Ants game?

I didn't find it on the current site or the older one.

Was the game inspired by anything like agent-based simulations?

I'm not super interested in what the tech industry is calling "agentic" AI, but I am interested in collective intelligence, see David Ha's work in this area: - https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/26339137221114... - https://neurips.cc/virtual/2024/105817

Would be cool if each ant itself could be an agent

reply
Unfortunately the competition site is mostly down and couldn't find much about the old competition other than the participants blog articles. Do a search on "Google Ants AI Challenge - post mortem", and you get a lot of articles around the game.

Thanks for sharing the research. I tried implementing a per Ant decision making model, but gave up as the training time was much longer compared to the current baseline. I think I should rethink the idea.

reply
Nice. I was 72nd. Working in AI research today and still making ai for games as a hobby (tfmbot.com is an ai i’m working on for my favourite board game terraforming mars).
reply
Thanks for sharing. I remember #1 xathis had a score, big leap ahead of others. The difference in techniques in top 100 was almost the same.
reply
I remember a game on Steam called Tiny Brains, great couch co-op.
reply
From competing with the world to building a place for the world to compete—what a full-circle moment. Love the challenge: how much strategy can a tiny neural network learn? Excited to see what people build.
reply
I remember the Google Ants challenge being pretty interesting. What made you choose strategy games for the new competition instead of something simpler like classic board games?
reply
Let's play real stuff.

"Playing Hex and Counter Wargames using Reinforcement Learning and Recurrent Neural Networks"

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2502.13918

reply
Is "Hex" real stuff? I know that from university AI courses, from before current ML phase. I thought this was a toy game invented specifically to be nice for AI exercises - bounded, easy to follow, moderate branching factor, and designed to make ties impossible.
reply
No no no it's not a game named Hex. It's a gaming genre where units move on a field of hexagons.
reply
Around 1997 there was something awfully similar to this doing the rounds, called AI Wars. IIRC it was code rather than weights, but it's a funny parallel. 30 years! God I'm old.
reply
This reminds me of John Conway's Game of Life. I wonder what surprises we could get by combining Game of Life with neural networks
reply
There is also MIT Battlecode - same idea, but for human teams

https://battlecode.org/

reply
This looks fun. How do you evaluate the networks — is it purely based on game performance, or are there other metrics like size and inference speed too?
reply
Glad you like it. The evaluation is based purely on game performance. However each weight class is evaluated separately. Nano, micro, mini, small, large and open class.
reply
When you submit a model it participates on both its weight class and the open class
reply
Man, I remember doing this is 2011 as well. Everything some kind of hand-coded strategy. I enjoyed it a lot.
reply
Pretty neat! I'm considering entering some models. How long will you be running these competitions?
reply
The current season is a public beta and ends by end of the month. After that am considering 3 month seasons.
reply
Signed up and submitted a test model. Now the real training begins!
reply
It would be cool for sb to try jev on it :P although this is not text input at all
reply
Interesting—how small can a neural network get and still make good strategic decisions? Curious whether these models can adapt to unfamiliar opponents.
reply
Great idea to focus on small, efficient neural networks.
reply
This looks fun. How small are the networks you're aiming for?
reply
the network size brackets are in TFA:

    nano up to 16 KiB
    micro up to 128 KiB 
    mini up to 1 MiB 
    small up to 8 MiB 
    large up to 64 MiB
reply
Each season has a different weight size restrictions. Currently open season is for a full production test.
reply
Reminds me of MechMania at UIUC - exciting!
reply
> Your class is measured, not chosen

> model and manifest bytes together pick the class

What?

How hard is it to write something like "your weight class is determined by the total size of the model and manifest" (if I understood it correctly).

Current version both sounds very AI-sloppy and is ambiguous.

The doc page [0] is even more painful to read.

[0] https://tinybrains.dev/docs/models/weight-classes.html

reply
Thanks for your feedback. I’ve fixed most text now. I did use AI to create the documentation earlier out of rush but now cleaned up everything.
reply
Not all sloppy writing is AI. Quite a few humans also write ambiguously.
reply
OMG!

Just yesterday I published my reworked GoNEAT library that implements HyperNEAT combined with phased search and backpropagation [1].

But it's kind of impossible to enter for me because of the hard pytorch requirements :( would love to see the project as a gym, so that you can run your own ANN design algorithm.

I get that most data science students still use python, but the evolutionary world is kinda in C++ and other native languages.

Anyways, great project nonetheless.

[1] https://github.com/cookiengineer/goneat

reply
Where do you see a hard requirement? I have added support for ONNX model upload for now and would love to extend support for other formats. How you build the model is totally upto you. I don’t check anything other than format and inference time and model size.
reply
Saw your repo and understood you question better. The requirement are now limiting Neural Networks only, not a direct algorithm implementation
reply
Cool idea!

It would help to delete all the text on the page, and write it without AI.

For example, "model and manifest bytes together pick the class; every version also plays on Open"

reply
Thanks for the feedback. I’ll take that as top priority.
reply
deleted
reply
reply
reply
Thanks for sharing. The primary reason building this website is to learn small neural networks and tuning.
reply
[flagged]
reply